Indeed, education possesses many of the attributes that make for great video games. There are clear levels of mastery that can be numerically scored. Student 'players' are ranked, and can compare rankings, in a national or global contest. Participation can be competitive or individual. The best education, like the best games, adapts to the students performance.Jane McGonigal is a leading champion of using video games to solve the world's problems, as she describes at length in her book, Reality Is Broken: Why Games Make Us Better and How They Can Change the World. Although the concept may sound trivial, it encapsulates deeper truths about human psychology and motivation.
Teaching Besieged
The teaching profession is under attack from the recession, and also by longer term economic trends. Consider:
- Education costs are rising faster than inflation and economic growth -- 15% in the last two years alone.
- Local governments are laying off school teachers -- 1.5% nationwide and up to 20% in some California school districts -- triggered by the global recession.
- As a result, class sizes are growing as teaching positions fail to keep pace with population growth.
Many believe that the solution lies with better hiring practices, a return to smaller class sizes, less lavish college campus amenities, and more active parent involvement in their children's education.
Others see a right-wing conspiracy to dismantle the public education system by starving public schools of resources until parents beg for a voucher system and turn to private schools. Success stories like the Waldorf Sarasota provide a counter example embraced by voucher enthusiasts.
Despite all of the partial solutions and politics, it's worth considering whether the following plot can be solved without a more radical transformation of the educational system.
The Teaching Profession Transformed
Teaching is already joining the list of shrinking professions radically transformed by technology.
- Computer software grades college admissions essays as reliably as human graders can. For now, people still review the essays as a sanity check.
- An online computer science course, Intro to AI (artificial intelligence), taught by Stanford professors enrolled 160,000 students and auditors from around the world.
- Silicon Valley startup Udacity Inc. is tackling the problem of provide affordable, high quality education that scales.
Innovations like online education and essay-grading software hold out some possibilities of bringing costs into line, and turning education into a software problem, making it possible to educate more people, to a higher standard, with even fewer teachers, and adding teaching to the expanding list of shrinking professions.
What do you think? Is teaching and education becoming a software problem? Will advances in gaming solve the challenges of keeping students engaged and learning without the physical presence of a teacher and classmates?
Related posts:
Why Gen Y Writes Better
Is Specialization Killing Liberal Arts Education?
Externalizing Knowledge


If you've ever attended a class where you learned as much or more from your classmates than your teacher, you know why classes with interaction are superior to video games. Certainly, there is a place for technology in the classroom and teachers welcome getting help in accessing the best videos, etc. that will engage students. But nothing beats a real, live (yes, small) class of students with a helpful, resourceful teacher and supportive parents.
ReplyDeleteAs for this comment: "Computer software grades college admissions essays as reliably as human graders can. For now, people still review the essays as a sanity check. " Students already game the system by having parents, teacher and consultants massage their college essays. They will learn to game the software just as people sprinkle the right words into their resumes. Better yet would be to place students in a classroom and give them a few hours to write their essay (alone). And have real people look it over.
First, thanks for the comments.
ReplyDeleteTo your first point, games where you can interact with your fellow players (classmates) are common and popular. It seems reasonable that similar concepts can be applied to education as well as to fantasy worlds.
Secondly, cheating has always been a problem. Teachers have learned to search the internet for plagiarized essays. Software improvements can help to catch cheating in an automated way, perhaps more effectively than teachers.
Initially, I expect that software tools will assist rather than replace teachers. Partly, they can help with grading efficiency, like machine grading of standardized multiple choice tests, or requiring students to submit typed assignments rather than handwritten ones. And partly, they have the potential to enable larger class sizes.
For now, it may seem inconceivable to supplement or replace teachers with technology. We've already made a few small steps in that direction though.
I agree with above comments. However the place I see technology/software used instead of teachers is to reach the under served. There are many places in the world that does not attract talented teachers. Sometimes it is due to geographical/location reasons and other times it is financial. So the regions that either dont have access to good or any education can totally benefit from software, video games driven learning.
ReplyDeleteOtherwise I think technology can be used to reduce cost of education and make it more effective. I don't think it can replace classrooms and teachers.
Excellent points. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the inspirational thoughts you wrote here. It is excellent to know that there are some people that can associate themselves to this issue. For everyone else, I advise that they take the time to read this.
ReplyDeleteBuy Coursework Online | GCSE Coursework | Science Coursework | Statistics Coursework | Sociology Coursework | UK Coursework Writing | Research Paper Writing
Great! a few months ago I had visited this blog, but I forget which article I read on this blog, I never thought in a single month this blog had more visitors than ever before. Good work friend, continue your blogging activities. greetings prosperous fellow bloggers.Term paper writing
ReplyDeletebuy term Papers online
buy cheap term Papers
Dissertation Writing services
Dissertation writing